Why fear and compliance is not the same as training dogs

24 August 2023

I sometimes hear people say that dogs are being stubborn, dominant and trying to get one over on us.

When dogs are puppies we may tolerate their behaviour and state that they’re just a puppy and still have time to learn. However when a dog hits about 5 months old our tolerance towards their behaviour is often shorter. The selective deafness, jumping up, chewing items, not coming back when called is sometimes deemed as refusal to listen. The adolescent period, is sadly, the time when most dogs get relinquished to a shelter as people cannot cope with their behaviour any more. People may tell you you need to give them a firm hand and show them who’s boss. This is wrong.


During the adolescent period there are massive brain changes. This makes everything so much more exciting than ever before. Dogs at this age really lack impulse control. They are not trying to punish you, and their behaviour  is not pre-meditated. This time, although hard, needs to be a time of understanding. Helping dogs by going to a calmer environment and setting them up to succeed doesn’t mean we are ‘making a rod for our own back’ or ‘being soft’. It shows that we understand dogs and their behaviour and want to help them and keep them safe. Punishing them by tapping them on the nose can lead to aggressive behaviour. Time out’s can build frustration. We also cannot communicate to them why we are doing this, so a hand punishing them can be intimidating and scary and lead them to fear hands.  This can damage the relationship and sever bonds.


Connection not correction is so vital at this stage. Compliance through fear can lead to dogs who are more unpredictable as they shut down. Allowing a dog to rehearse a behaviour during adolescence may result in an engrained behaviour.


by Lisa Sinnott • 23 October 2026
Have you ever noticed your dog putting the brakes on during a walk, pulls, refusing to move, not wanting to go out or panting when they hear a noise? They may be experiencing a sensitivity to noise.
by Lisa Sinnott • 7 October 2026
Should Your Dog Sleep on Your Bed?
by Lisa Sinnott • 8 September 2026
Is your dog regularly barking and lunging at other dogs on a walk? There could be a number of reasons this occurs including frustration at not being able to access a dog or if they are worried and saying move away
by Lisa Sinnott • 1 September 2026
Reasons behind repetitive behaviour in dogs such as licking of surfaces can be due to a host of reasons. As a behaviourist it is my job to work out why it’s occuring!
by Lisa Sinnott • 3 August 2026
Everyone Has an Opinion, But Confidence Doesn't Always Mean Competence
by Lisa Sinnott • 27 July 2026
Information on mounting/humping
by Lisa Sinnott • 7 July 2026
This is when a dog ingests non - food items such as rocks, stones, dirt, fabric.
by Lisa Sinnott • 24 June 2026
A dog barking at night can feel frustrating and annoying – you know they need sleep and you need it too.
by Lisa Sinnott • 15 June 2026
Here is some information about aggression.
by Lisa Sinnott • 12 June 2026
If your dog barks, lunges, growls, or becomes overwhelmed around other dogs, people, or situations, you're not alone. Reactivity is one of the most common challenges dog owners face, and understanding why it happens is the first step towards helping your dog feel calmer and more confident.